SUMMARY
Steady progress while the cost of money keeps rising
The Fund generated a return of 1.2% during the month of October, which compares favourably with 0.7% for the market (All Ords) and 0.4% for our target of the RBA cash rate plus 6%. It brings the return for the financial year to date to 5.7%, and 12.2% for the last six months.
We are pleased with this result, particularly given how cautiously we have been positioned. The portfolio has been run on very conservative settings all year, with elevated cash levels, currently over 10%, and a focus on businesses that generate real cash flows today.






COMMENTARY
Backdrop
The cost of money continues to go up. The RBA lifted the cash rate again in early November to 4.85%, its fifth increase this year, and Australian 10-year bond yields spent much of October around 5.4%, levels last seen in 2011. In the US, the picture is much the same, with the 10-year Treasury yield well above 5%. Oil above US$100 a barrel has not helped the inflation outlook.
Markets have found this hard to digest. October started with the ASX 200 falling 2% in a single day and every sector in the red. The mood swung back and forth through the month as each new inflation print and central bank comment was read for clues. In our experience, this kind of environment rewards patience far more than activity.
High rates and long duration assets
It is worth spending a moment on why higher rates matter so much more for some assets than others. The value of any asset is simply the cash it will produce in the future, discounted back to today at the prevailing cost of money. For a business that earns most of its cash this year and next, a higher discount rate makes little difference. For a “long duration” asset, one whose cash flows are expected far into the future, it makes an enormous difference. A dollar received next year is worth about 3% less when the discount rate moves from 5% to 8%. A dollar received in twenty years is worth about 43% less. For a decade of near-zero rates, investors were prepared to pay almost any price for growth that was a long way off, because money cost them nothing to wait. That is no longer the case. Highly rated technology and growth companies, many property and infrastructure assets, and businesses yet to turn a profit all sit at the long end of this curve, and their valuations remain exposed while the cost of money stays where it is. We have deliberately focussed the portfolio on quality businesses, robust balance sheets that minimise the negative impact of higher interest rates and, most importantly, businesses that generate real after-tax cash now, bought at prices that do not rely on a distant future going exactly to plan.
The Portfolio
The best contributors in October were: ResMed, that delivered another solid quarter, with revenue up 6%, gross margins higher, and more than US$1 billion of cash handed back to shareholders through buybacks and dividends. Cleanaway, that agreed to a takeover by EQT at $3.095 a share, a 32% premium to where it traded before the approach, and a useful reminder that private capital can see value in good, unexciting businesses even when the share market cannot. Aristocrat, BlueScope and IAG, that also added meaningfully.
The largest detractor was Maas Group, which gave back much of its September gain after Firmus pulled its planned ASX float. Fortunately we had sold the greater part of our holding into strength prior to this. Evolution Mining, Ampol and BHP also gave back some of their enormous gains in prior months as commodity prices eased, and our new position in Zip (−0.29%) had a soft first full month.
We were net sellers during the month, selling $9.6 million of stock and buying $2.6 million. We took profits in IAG, BlueScope, ResMed and Metcash after strong runs, and continued to trim Ampol and Maas Group. We added to Zip aggressively, using the weakness to build the position, and also added a little to Seek ($0.4 million). Cash finished the month at 10.4%, which gives us the flexibility to act when prices become more attractive, which we suspect they will.
The portfolio continues to generate a forward after-tax cash earnings yield of around 6.8%. That is real cash, earned today, by businesses that do not need low interest rates to justify their share prices.
Outlook
The RBA’s split vote in November suggests the end of this tightening cycle may be getting closer, but we are not prepared to bet the portfolio on it. Inflation is still well above target, and the cost of money is likely to stay high for some time yet. In that world, the price paid for an asset matters a great deal again, and we think that favours the type of businesses we own.
We remain as focused as ever on our primary objectives of capital preservation and generating a reasonable real return. We will continue to do this by owning a variety of good businesses, run by honest and competent management teams, bought at the right price.